The Catherine Wheel | Performing Arts Review | Chicago Reader

The Catherine Wheel 

Sign up for our newsletters Subscribe

The Catherine Wheel, Bailiwick Repertory.

Halberstadt, Prussia, 1717: Catherine Linck, disguised as a man, meets and marries Catherine Muhlhahn, and the two women live together as husband and wife for four years until they're arrested on a charge of sodomy. Their trial, recounted in court records of 1721, entails much legal and theological discourse on the question of whether women are technically capable of such a crime.

Playwright Ingrid MacDonald bases The Catherine Wheel on this true story, but to make her play a complete narrative with fully drawn characters would have required more research and imagination than she reveals here. She sketches in the lovers' backgrounds in a series of short scenes and in dialogue that jumbles together poetic and colloquial speech ("My blood talks to me...I wanna fuck her!") in a manner that's meant to suggest Brecht but comes closer to a comic book. This impression is heightened by L.M. Attea's staging: her cast play their roles in a broad, cartoon style. Amanda McCluskey's Linck swaggers and huffs like Mighty Mouse, slapping around Molly Glynn Hammond's childlike Kathy until she threatens, in the best TV-movie tradition, to kick him out if he doesn't behave. The other characters--a shrewish mother, a sympathetic prostitute, assorted male pigs--are likewise shallow, driven only by the plot.

An interesting play and a timely lesson might have been crafted from the story of this persecuted lesbian couple. But Bailiwick's propagandistic production simply preaches to the choir--the only audience likely to take this underdeveloped parable seriously.


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

More by Mary Shen Barnidge

Agenda Teaser

Performing Arts
Peter Pan Mercury Theater Chicago
November 17
Performing Arts
Blue Man Group Briar Street Theatre
August 14

Tabbed Event Search

Popular Stories