An analysis of Senator Kirk's charter school 'analysis' | On Politics | Chicago Reader

An analysis of Senator Kirk's charter school 'analysis' 

Mark Kirk claims that Chicago’s top high schools are charters, but that doesn’t mean it’s true

Sign up for our newsletters Subscribe

One day last month, an Evanston resident named Zoe Zolbrod came across an e-mail blast from the office of U.S. senator Mark Kirk with the headline, "9 of the top Ten High Schools in Chicago are Charter Schools."

Kirk's declaration took Zolbrod by surprise. "I don't pretend to be an expert," says Zolbrod, an editor at a publishing house. "But I do know that nine out of the top ten performing high schools in Chicago are definitely not charters."

In this case, you don't have to be an expert—you, like me, can just go to the website of the state board of education to see exactly which schools are doing how well in the great test-taking game.

It turns out that Zolbrod was right: nine out of the ten top-scoring high schools in Chicago are not charters.

In fact, if you use ACT scores as the measurement, as Senator Kirk did, you'll discover that none of the top ten public high schools in Chicago is a charter.

That's none—as in zero.

Now, before I go further, let me say this: I'm usually the last person in the world to start throwing test scores around. I don't think much of using a test to try to measure how schools, teachers, parents, and especially children are progressing.

But since Senator Kirk raised the subject . . .

The highest-ranking charter, Chicago Virtual, ranks 11th. Its average ACT score for the 2010 to 2011 school year was 20.1—well below the 29.2 average at Northside College Prep, which tops the list.

That's not all. It seems that only two of the top 20 are charters—Noble Street Charter also cracks the top 20 list with 19.9.

As a matter of fact, nine of the 13 charter high schools that reported ACT scores were below the system's 17.7 average.

In short, most regular high schools in Chicago—with their unionized teachers—are beating the charters, at least when it comes to ACT scores. But don't hold your breath waiting for Senator Kirk to send that out in an e-mail blast.

Comments (31)

Showing 1-25 of 31

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-25 of 31

Add a comment

More by Ben Joravsky

  • Feast to famine

    Feast to famine

    Just last year Chicago had billions for Amazon but now it’s suddenly too broke for schoolkids.
    • Oct 22, 2019
  • Listen to <em>The Ben&nbsp;Joravsky Show</em>

    Listen to The Ben Joravsky Show

    The Ben Joravsky Show is streamed Tuesdays through Fridays between 1 and 3 PM and airs live on the Chicago Reader and Sun-Times websites. It is also being released as a podcast each day after the live taping.
    • Oct 22, 2019
  • The show goes on

    The show goes on

    One era ends and another begins for our beloved First Tuesdays.
    • Oct 16, 2019
  • More »

Agenda Teaser

Lit & Lectures
October 22
Galleries & Museums
October 22

Tabbed Event Search

Popular Stories