Please Give | Chicago Reader

Please Give

The witty and perceptive writer-director Nicole Holofcener (Walking and Talking, Lovely & Amazing, Friends With Money) delivers her best feature yet, a sharp-elbowed philosophical comedy that ponders why people find it so hard to be generous with one another. Catherine Keener and Oliver Platt are a married couple in Midtown Manhattan who've bought the apartment next door to their own but won't get it until the death of the sour old lady living there (Ann Guilbert, who decades ago played Millie the neighbor on The Dick Van Dyke Show). Rebecca Hall and Amanda Peet are the old woman's granddaughters, who've spent years trying to deal with her niggardly outlook on life. The comedy is wonderfully barbed, but there are also some genuinely loving moments that reveal Holofcener's own generosity as a writer; this is one of those rare movies that made me want to thank the person who did it.



  • Nicole Holofcener


  • Catherine Keener
  • Amanda Peet
  • Oliver Platt
  • Rebecca Hall
  • Ann Morgan Guilbert
  • Sarah Steele
  • Lois Smith
  • Thomas Ian Nicholas


  • Anthony Bregman
  • Caroline Jaczko

Related Stories

  • The Best Movies of 2010

    The Best Movies of 2010

    Carlos, Enter the Void, Dogtooth, and more
    • Dec 16, 2010
  • When Giving Hurts

    When Giving Hurts

    Nicole Holofcener ponders the pitfalls of generosity in Please Give
    • May 6, 2010

What others are saying

  • Now Playing

    By Film...

    By Theater...