Free Your Mind | Letters | Chicago Reader

Free Your Mind 

Sign up for our newsletters Subscribe


As if having to deal with the impenetrable whinings of film critic Jonathan Rosenbaum weren't enough, now we have filmgoers like Harris Meyer (December 2 Letters), crying about Rosenbaum?! Give me a break. Why anybody in their right mind would go to a movie, hoping for a "postmodernist cinematic breakthrough" is completely beyond me. Movies are entertainment. Period. Any other self-important film school dithering is pointless. You pays your $7.50, you takes your chances. If you didn't like it, for whatever reason, so what? Film critics aren't God, and great movies slip through the cracks every week. But gee whiz, knock off the crying.

A big reason Roger Ebert is one of the best movie critics extant is that he recognizes that films are entertainment. Escapist bits of fun, perfect for whiling away an evening.

When Rosenbaum calls Pulp Fiction "flamboyant surface," he and Mr. Meyer should realize that almost every damn film made is! There aren't any big messages, or life-changing revelations. It's just a bunch of pictures, put together for the enjoyment of the audience. Some are great, some suck, but hey, that's how life is. Deal with it.

I reckon films that aren't mere entertainment play at the Music Box, so that cognoscenti can sit through some three-hour, subtitled bit of repressed Euro-filmmaking, then dissect it afterwards.

Pulp Fiction was one of the most enjoyable films I have seen in many years, full of great moments and little details. I howled with laughter during the Marvin-gets-shot-in-the-face bit, and the Christopher Walken speech about the watch was hysterical. This movie was exciting, the dialogue was fantastic, even the music killed. It was organized, quite coherent, and the way that Tarantino played with time was delightful. To call this film, as Mr. Meyer did, a "cynical fraud on an already violence-besotted public" is one of the dumbest criticisms I have ever heard. Had he watched carefully, he would have seen that the violence in the movie was not the point of the film, but purely incidental, just something that happened to the character. The characters lived in a violent world, and sometimes, violent things happened to them.

Mr. Meyer hopes that people who see this film will be more discerning than Mr. Rosenbaum, and not succumb to trendiness. He has the first half of his wish. That's why the success of Pulp Fiction, and for that matter, Reservoir Dogs and True Romance, the other Tarantino flicks, have as much to do with word of mouth as any critical meanderings.

Films are subjective, so everybody has the right to like or dislike anything they choose. But don't rag because you took some mope's advice and didn't like something. That's why we have minds . . . to use. And please, don't follow Mr. Meyer's advice. Encourage your friends to see Pulp Fiction, so they can make up their own minds. After all, that's why there's Chocolate and Vanilla.

Kevin Williams


Support Independent Chicago Journalism: Join the Reader Revolution

We speak Chicago to Chicagoans, but we couldn’t do it without your help. Every dollar you give helps us continue to explore and report on the diverse happenings of our city. Our reporters scour Chicago in search of what’s new, what’s now, and what’s next. Stay connected to our city’s pulse by joining the Reader Revolution.

Are you in?

  Give $35/month →  
  Give $10/month →  
  Give  $5/month  → 

Not ready to commit? Send us what you can!

 One-time donation  → 


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Agenda Teaser

Performing Arts
September 24
Performing Arts
September 18

Popular Stories

  • What happened to YOUmedia?

    The Chicago Public Library's flagship teen program was a refuge for Black and Brown youth. Recent layoffs put that in jeopardy.
  • Queer folks of color want to cancel today’s Buttigieg-Lightfoot book event 13

    Activists say the pair's public conversation about “trust and distrust” shows the problems with assuming marginalized people have progressive values.
  • How I Made It in Comedy: Bob Odenkirk

    "I had a meeting about writing a movie script for Francis the Talking Mule, which was a really dumb idea. I thought, What did the executives see in my past work that made them think I’m the perfect guy to write this?"
  • Chicago's budget crisis, explained 2

    Budget season is here but it’s more dogged than usual. How will the city recover from a nearly billion-dollar budget gap?
  • Surfing Sandy

    Lake Michigan's turbulent waters offer die-hard surfers a prime opportunity to shred some waves