You searched for:

Start over

Narrow Search

Best Window Seat 

Hoosier Mama Pie Company

1618½ W. Chicago
312-243-4846

hoosiermamapie.com

The other day I asked my wife: “What would be the best possible thing that could happen to our neighborhood on Sunday afternoons?” It was a leading question: I expected her to guess that Hoosier Mama had added Sunday hours (which it had: 10 AM to 4 PM).

When former Trio pastry chef Paula Haney opened her heritage-pie shop in East Village, her reputation preceded her; I’d already tried her wares at the Green City Market and looked forward to taking home as many pies as my wallet or pants could afford. But the combination of a window seat, single slices, and Metropolis coffee means I’m more likely than not to linger.

It’s not just any window seat: Haney’s shop is small, and the table, with its built-in pastel wooden benches and homey accessories, takes up the whole front of the space. It’s like a breakfast nook away from home, modestly decked out in the style of a farmhouse kitchen or timeless midwestern mom-and-pop restaurant. I can’t recommend a better way to while away an afternoon than in Hoosier Mama’s sunlit window with black coffee and a slice of vinegar chess pie. But don’t linger too long, because that’s probably me waiting for you to finish.

Critics' Picks

Best Middle Eastern Restaurant

3129 S. Morgan St. 773-254-6300
Zaytune Mediterranean Grill continue

Best Manti

Cafe Orchid continue

Best Use of a Pernicious Weed

Kimpira at Masu Izakaya continue

Best New Neighborhood Restaurant

1119 W. Webster Ave. 773-472-7070
Kith & Kin continue

Best Hand Food

Mystery corn dawg at Franks 'n' Dawgs continue

Best New Burger

Charburger at Edzo's Burger Shop, Evanston, Illinois continue

Best New Veggie Burger

505 N. State St. 312-755-9704
Wild mushroom-brown rice burger at Sable Kitchen & Bar continue

Best Fries

Foie Gras Fries at Big & Littles continue

Best Theoretical Food Truck

Tamale Space Charros continue

Best Squid Balls

Sweet Station continue

Best Place to Sup Like Henry VIII

Benny's Chop House on a Wednesday evening continue

Best Location for a Clandestine Tryst, With Dinner

Pescatore Palace, Franklin Park, Illinois continue

Best Unorthodox Pizza Topping

1927 W. North Ave. 773-772-4422
Spinach and Mashed Potato at Piece Brewery & Pizzeria continue

Best Way to Stuff Your Face With Thai Food for Under $5

Two-for-one coupons at Cozy Noodles & Rice continue

Best Coffee Roaster

1432 W. Irving Park Rd. 773-661-6530
Asado Coffee Company continue

Best Restaurant Name

Cheogajip/Chicken and Pizza Love Letter, Niles, Illinois continue

Best Breakfast Cocktail

The Easy Virtue at The Drawing Room continue

Best Beer Cocktail

The Michelada at Big Star continue

Best Canned Beer Made in Chicago

4257 N. Lincoln Ave. 773-248-4038
Half Acre continue

Best Use of Wild Midwestern Persimmons

Persimmon Solera from Purgatory Cellars continue

Best Place to Try Palm Wine

Bolat African Cuisine continue

Best Macarons

Macaron Chicago continue

Best Chocolates

Mayana Chocolate continue

Best Use of Leftover Cake

Cake balls at Bleeding Heart Bakery, Chicago and Oak Park, Illinois continue

Best Window Seat

Hoosier Mama Pie Company continue

Best Regional Cheese

Otter Creek Spring Cheddar continue

Best Food Co-op

Dill Pickle Food Co-op continue

Best Chef's Blog

Paul Fehribach of Big Jones continue
(Sorry, no information is currently available for other years in this same award category.)