A Wonderful Life | Performing Arts Review | Chicago Reader

A Wonderful Life 

Sign up for our newsletters Subscribe

A WONDERFUL LIFE, Candlelight Dinner Playhouse. Frank Capra's holiday classic, now a half century old, is more than a poor man's Christmas Carol: George Bailey is the Job of Bedford Falls, giving up a trip to Europe, college education, honeymoon, and career as an architect to serve his dad's building and loan association. Without supernatural intervention, the next sacrifice would be his life. It's a story almost too strong for songs.

Especially if it's Joe Raposo's aggressively mediocre, instantly forgettable score, forlornly yoked to a tepidly faithful book and lyrics by the once-formidable Sheldon Harnick. Imagine George's desperation without urgency or momentum, and you still overestimate this musical Wonderful Life. The subsubstandard songs trivialize, dilute, and retard what should be full-blooded characters and a swift-paced plot. Worse, the script doesn't begin to suggest the warmhearted partnership between suicidal George and guardian angel Clarence; they might as well be in separate stories. Little happens here that's not predetermined: when a transformed George returns home to ask pardon from all-suffering Mary, his friends have already raised the missing money; in the film, it happens spontaneously.

Heartfelt if softheaded, William Pullinsi's staging offers creditable clones of the celluloid icons. Robert Gallagher makes an ardent if erratic George, Kate Fry a solid Mary despite her silly solos. Dale Benson's Clarence twinkles unctuously, and, though the part is truncated, Dale Morgan incarnates greed as Mr. Potter. Well, it's still a wonderful film.

--Lawrence Bommer


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

More by Lawrence Bommer

Agenda Teaser

Performing Arts
Manic Mondays Frances Cocktail Lounge
November 20
Performing Arts
Duck and Cover Classroom The Time Gallery
August 10

Tabbed Event Search

Popular Stories