Martin to Coconate: I Wish I Could but I Can't | Bleader

Monday, October 13, 2008

Martin to Coconate: I Wish I Could but I Can't

Posted By on 10.13.08 at 12:52 PM

Sign up for our newsletters Subscribe

The good news for Frank Coconate -- the man Mayor Daley backers love to hate -- is that he's inching closer to getting back his old job and fully clearing his name.

In 2006 the city fired him from his job in the water department, claiming he was goofing off on the job.

He countered that he was really fired for being a whistle-blower and openly urging [PDF] Congressman Jesse Jackson to run against Mayor Daley in last year's election.

Last summer hearing officer Roger Balla and the city's human resources board, which is appointed by Mayor Daley, upheld the city's firing [scroll down]. Coconate appealed and his case came before Cook County judge LeRoy K. Martin.

Last week Martin ruled that though he disagreed with the severity of the board's punishment, he felt obliged to go along with it because he didn't think he could "substitute" his "opinion" for the city's hearing officer and human resources board.

"I'm bound to affirm the board's decision if, in fact, the board -- if there's any basis at all for the board to reach its decision," Martin ruled. "The -- and it's probably not proper, so I won't go into any detail, but I can think of other decisions that I've been involved in and other decisions that I'm aware of that would seem to me to be a lot more egregious than the things that they -- that the city has leveled against Mr. Coconate. And considering the amount of service that he's given to the city, I am of the opinion that the decision to discharge him would probably not have been my decision either. Quite frankly, I don't think that the punishment fits the crime, even assuming what the city says is correct."

What? The whole point of a losing party appealing to a higher court is to convince a judge or panel of judges to substitute their ruling for that of the lower court. That's why they call it an appeal. If Judge Martin didn't think he had the power to overturn the board's ruling, he should have saved both sides -- city and Cocoante -- the time and trouble of presenting their cases. 

By the way, Martin's confession of helplessness in the Coconate case offers an interesting contrast to his ruling in the matter of Joseph Annunzio, the city transportation department supervisor who was fired for making racist comments to coworkers.

Last November, the human resources board ruled that there was not enough reason to fire Annunzio, the nephew of former congressman Frank Annunzio. The city appealed the ruling; on July 11, Judge Martin overruled the board and upheld Annunzio's firing.

Coconate says he will appeal Judge Martin's ruling to the appellate court.

Tags: , , ,

Comments (17)

Showing 1-17 of 17

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-17 of 17

Add a comment

More by Ben Joravsky

  • Listen to <em>The Ben&nbsp;Joravsky Show</em>

    Listen to The Ben Joravsky Show

    The Ben Joravsky Show is streamed Tuesdays through Fridays between 1 and 3 PM and airs live on the Chicago Reader and Sun-Times websites. It is also being released as a podcast each day after the live taping.
    • Oct 16, 2019
  • The show goes on

    The show goes on

    One era ends and another begins for our beloved First Tuesdays.
    • Oct 16, 2019
  • Size matters

    Size matters

    Chicago teachers have almost no relief for overcrowded classrooms.
    • Oct 9, 2019
  • More »

Agenda Teaser

Performing Arts
Love and Information Trap Door Theatre
September 12
Performing Arts
His Shadow 16th Street Theater, Berwyn Cultural Center
September 05

Tabbed Event Search

The Bleader Archive

Popular Stories