Chicago Reader [Chicago Reader - Fall Arts & Entertainment Guide - Everywhere on Sept 11] [CHICAGO DRINKS: Your drink specials guide]

 

Sign up for our E-Newsletters:
 


Reader Info
Advertising, subscriptions, staff, privacy policy, contact info, freelancers' guidelines, etc.

[Reader Free Tix: African Festival of the Arts - Aug 29 - Sept 1 - Washington Park]

[CHICAGO DRINKS]




Digg! Digg this | Post to del.icio.us | E-mail E-mail this to a friend

Savage Love

April 4, 2008 | Past Columns
[This week's Savage Love can be found here.]

I thought I could bang out a column today—a regular column, a column about my readers’ problems and their freaky fetishes and all those asshole politicians out there. You know, the usual.

The day my son was born, I managed to slip out of the maternity ward and write a column; I wrote one the day I was indicted by the state of Iowa for licking Gary Bauer’s doorknobs. (I was actually indicted for voter fraud—on a trumped-up charge, your honor—but Bauer’s knob needs all the attention it can get.) I’ve written columns on days that I was dumped and on the morning of 9/11. So I figured that I could bang out a column today.

I opened my laptop and started reading your letters. I love reading your letters—I do. But I couldn’t get into it. I’m disappointed in myself. I write this column at Ann Landers’s desk, for crying out loud, and the old lady banged out a heartbreaking, truncated column when her marriage collapsed. If Landers could bang one out under that kind of emotional strain, then I could damn well bang one out, too. Just do it, right? Just fucking do it. But I just fucking can’t.

My mother died on Monday.

Perhaps a sex-advice column isn’t an appropriate place to eulogize an articulate, elegant woman, a practicing Catholic named for the patron saint of hopeless causes and, perhaps consequently, a Cubs fan. So let’s not think of this as a eulogy. Let’s think of it as a thank-you note, the kind of nicety that my mother appreciated.

Forgive the cliche: My mom gave me so much. She gave me life, of course, and some other stuff besides: her sense of humor, her bionic bullshit detectors, her colossal sweet tooth. She also gave me—she gave all four of her children (Bill, Ed, Dan, Laura)—her unconditional love. Long after I came out, she told me she always suspected that I might be gay; I was the quiet one, the boy who liked Broadway musicals and baking cakes and who shared her passion for Strauss waltzes. When I asked my parents to take me to the national tour of A Chorus Line for my 13th birthday, that should have settled the matter. (Your third son? Total fag, lady.) But my parents were Catholic and religious so it was still a shock when I told them. My mother came around fast and she came out swinging—rainbow stickers on her car, a PFLAG membership card in her wallet, and an ultimatum delivered to the whole family: anyone who had a problem with me had a problem with her.

But the real reason I feel compelled to thank her in this space is because I wouldn’t have this space if it weren’t for her.

My mother, as my brother Bill likes to say, made friends like Rockefeller made money and George W. Bush makes mistakes—and she was that friend you confided in and went to for advice. I was a mama’s boy—hello—and I spent a great deal of time in my mother’s kitchen listening to her tell her friends exactly what they needed to do. Sometimes gently, sometimes brusquely, always with a dose of humor. My mom liked to say that her son got paid to do something that she did for free—and isn’t that the way the world works? Women cook, men are chefs; women are housewives, men are butlers; she gave advice, I got paid to give advice. (And for a few years, she did too; we wrote a column together for a couple of Web sites in the 1990s.)

So I want to thank my mom. I wouldn’t be writing this column if it weren’t for her gifts and her ability to find the humor in even the most serious of subjects.

Even death, even her own.

After a long struggle, we had to go into my mother’s hospital room and tell her that nothing more could be done. She didn’t go into the hospital expecting to die and she was not ready go. But she took the news with characteristic grace. She said her farewells, asked us never to forget her (as if), and paused for a moment. Then she lifted an eyebrow, shrugged, and said . . . “Shit.”

My mother wasn’t crude; I didn’t get my foul mouth from her. She used profanity sparingly and then only in italics and quotation marks. When she said “shit” on her deathbed, we understood the joke. What she meant was this: “Now, the kind of person who casually uses profanity might be inclined to say ‘shit’ at a moment like this. But I’m not the kind of person who casually uses profanity—and certainly not at a moment like this. But if I were the kind of person who casually used profanity, ‘shit’ might be the word I would use right now. If I were that kind of person. Which I’m not.”

Everyone who gathered around her bed—my mother’s husband (my son has two fathers and so do I), my sister, my aunt—knew why she said it: she wanted us to laugh. This woman, so full of life, wanting so badly to live, having just been told she would not—she was trying to lift our spirits. (“Shit,” for the record, wasn’t her last word. Her last words were just for the family.)

Anyway, my mom is dead, and I am not in the mood, as she used to say. (“You are so,” one of us kids would usually respond. “You’re in a bad mood.”) So I’m going to take a week or two off, from the column and the podcast, hang out with the boyfriend and the kid, and burst into tears in coffee shops and grocery stores. I’ll run some greatest hits in this space while I’m away—I’ll find a column or two featuring mom—and then I’ll be back, just as filthy minded as ever. In lieu of flowers, please send pictures of your boyfriend’s rear end. (Lesbians may send flowers.) If you’re the donation-making type and you’re so inclined, my mother would be pleased to see some of your money flow to PFLAG (pflag.org) or the Pulmonary Fibrosis Foundation (pulmonaryfibrosis.org).

Oh, one last thing: I was supposed to take my mother to see the national tour of The Drowsy Chaperone in Chicago at the Cadillac Palace this Friday, April 11. It was her birthday present. I got us great seats: seventh row, on the aisle. But I won’t be able to use our tickets now. Not because it would be too depressing to go without my mother—not just because—but because, as rotten, stinking fate would have it, I’m going to be at my mother’s wake on Friday night.

But I’m practical, like Mom, and I’d hate to see perfectly good tickets to a national tour of a hit Broadway musical go to waste. And it occurs to me that there has to be a teenage boy out there—in Chicago or close enough—who likes musicals and has a mother who loves him for the little musical-theater queen that he is. If you know that boy or you are that boy or you were that boy a decade ago or if you’re that boy’s mother or grandmother, send me an e-mail and I’ll arrange to get these tickets to you.

Like I said, they’re great seats. I would go if I could. But I can’t.

Shit.

Write to mail@savagelove.net.

Send a letter to the editor.

Comments

Flag as inappropriate

Cindy H at 1:19 PM on 4/4/2008

My heart goes out to your for your loss. Thank you for sharing this story with us. It was beautifully done - your Mother is proud.

Flag as inappropriate

Terry O'Sullivan at 2:27 PM on 4/4/2008

Dear Dan:
Fully expect to be thinking about your mother every day for a year, at least. And crying half of those days. But one day, you'll find that a day has passed that you didn't think about your mother. On that day, go tell your son and incredible story about his grandmother, a funny one. And make him laugh. You'll laugh, and you'll know that life does in fact, go on. And your mother, your source of life will be traveling with you in that life.

Flag as inappropriate

Terry O'Sullivan at 2:37 PM on 4/4/2008

Dear Dan:
Fully expect to be thinking about your mother every day for a year, at least. And crying half of those days. But one day, you'll find that a day has passed that you didn't think about your mother. On that day, go tell your son an incredible story about his grandmother, a funny one. And make him laugh. You'll laugh, and you'll know that life does in fact, go on. And your mother, your source of life will be traveling with you in that life.

Flag as inappropriate

Nancy T at 5:15 PM on 4/4/2008

Thank you, Dan, talking about your mother. Please don't think it weak or wrong not to write a regular column right now. It's human in the most wonderful way- being able to share your feelings.

Flag as inappropriate

JC at 5:39 PM on 4/4/2008

I cried as a read this because, after over a decade of reading your column, I feel like your mother was our mother, too. She seemed just like the kind of woman who would have produced an amazing, no-nonsense son like you. I'm sure she was proud, and I'm so sorry she's gone.

Flag as inappropriate

Frank B at 5:46 PM on 4/4/2008

Dan: I'm a friend of your brother Bill and my deepest sympathies are extended to your entire family. I lost my ma thirteen years ago and it still hurts. But you'll find from time-to-time a song playing that will remind you of her; and even though it may be trite to say, your ma continues to shine through her kids and friends. Peace.

Flag as inappropriate

Tina Lee at 7:03 PM on 4/4/2008

Dan, I am sorry for your loss. For all the brazenly uncompromising advice you often give people going through a difficult experience, it has always been clear to us readers that this advise is built from the foundation of true love for the human spirit to endure...this, I know you will do Dan and do it with gracious humor.

Flag as inappropriate

Katia at 7:57 PM on 4/4/2008

Dear Dan,

I've been where you are right now. When my beloved, brilliant father died when I was 23, I thought my life was over. That life was. But little by little, it was supplanted by another one, better in some ways, worse in others. I just want to tell you that although you are in absolute hell right now, it will get better, excruciatingly slowly, but it will feel better.

My deepest sympathy.

Flag as inappropriate

Leticia at 8:55 PM on 4/4/2008

Dan, I am so sorry for your loss, thank you for being so open and sharing your pain. I wish there were more parents like your mother, you were blessed and will continue to be blessed with her memory. Peace.

Flag as inappropriate

Paul R at 12:19 AM on 4/5/2008

Dear Dan,

I am a member of the cast of "The Drowsy Chaperone", and I also happen to be based in Chicago when I'm not on tour. I've read and enjoyed your column over the years, and was very saddened to hear about the passing of your mom.

Several of us in the cast of "Drowsy" have a ritual before every show called The Circle of Gratitude. It was an idea borrowed from the Original Broadway Cast, who also did it before each show, and it was carried over to us by Georgia Engel, who is our unofficial "leader" of the group.

In the Circle, we all join hands and voice what we're grateful for, in an effort to center ourselves in a positive energy before the show. However, we also take the opportunity to send strength to those individuals we know of who need "spiritual lifting up" on that particular day.

I want you to know that 5 minutes before the show on Friday, April 11th, our cast will be lifting up you and your family, and sending you all our strength. I will share with the Circle how grateful you are to have had such a wonderful mother, and I know they will all join me without hesitation in dedicating our Performance that night to her...

With Deepest Empathy,

Paul

Flag as inappropriate

Mark Yacko at 12:41 AM on 4/5/2008

Dear Dan~
I am 53. Mom is 92. I pray I die before she does because I just would know what to do without her.

Flag as inappropriate

roy mock at 2:36 AM on 4/5/2008

dear dan,

i'm so sorry for your loss. i read and/or listen to your column every week. thank you for being such a well-grounded person - i know your mother had a lot to do with it, but We still have to choose to use the gifts our parents share with us. i had to say some thing 'cause i couldn't sleep. i lost a dear friend last week; his memorial service is today. this hurts...

take care

Flag as inappropriate

Suzanne at 6:16 PM on 4/5/2008

Dear Dan
I cried when I read about your mom. Isn't it strange? I don't even know her (heck, I don't even know you), but through your words today and through your column every thursday I could tell that she was good people, and I've noticed a lot of good people go too soon for no good reason. Please know a lot of strangers are thinking of you, your mom and your family and sending good ju ju your way.
My deepest sympathies.

Flag as inappropriate

Lisa Murphy at 12:52 AM on 4/7/2008

I'm so sorry.

Flag as inappropriate

Tony Fitzpatrick at 10:03 AM on 4/7/2008

Dan:

I am a friend of your brother Bill and a long-time reader of yours. Bless your Mom-- for her wisdom, compassion and her amazing kids -- I will hold out my best thought for her.

Flag as inappropriate

Mars in Chicago at 10:23 AM on 4/7/2008

Dan: Thank you for sharing this with us. The fact that you're still thinking of others at this time is impressive. My thoughts are with you and your family.

Flag as inappropriate

John at 10:59 AM on 4/7/2008

I'm really sorry Dan.

Flag as inappropriate

Naomi at 2:20 PM on 4/7/2008

Dear Dan,

Yep -- go love that kid like crazy. You'll be amazed at how it will help.

We are all grieving with you, and wishing that we could take the hurt away. Come back to Chicago and I'll cook you a kickass meal and tell you what a gift your Mom and her third son have been to the world as I know it.

Wishing you nurture and peace.

Flag as inappropriate

Natalie B. at 4:21 PM on 4/7/2008

Hello,

I typically never write responses to articles I read, but I felt compelled to respond to your editorial. First, and foremost, I wish you the best in your time of need and am truly sorry for your loss. As I write this, I am filled with bittersweet emotion. You see, I too, share an incredible relationship with my mom. She is the pillar of our family, the friend you can turn to when the rest of the world has turned against you, the person who will hold your darkest secret close to her heart.

Last week, she was diagnosed with Stage 4 Lung Cancer.

My mother had been a smoker for most of her life, starting at the age of 15, quitting just a month ago at age 69. She's accepted her recent prognosis with a strength and boldness that has uplifted the entire family in this difficult time. While it's impossible to determine how long she has left, I am forced to prepare myself, if there is such a thing, for what will ultimately be one of the most difficult things I may ever have to endure…losing my mom.

I commend you for your strength and humor in dealing with your loss. You have inspired me to further celebrate every moment I have left with her. I wish you and your family the best. God bless.

Flag as inappropriate

Ima at 4:23 PM on 4/7/2008

Be strong, Dan!
Guys out there -- do as Dan did; come out to your moms ... Don't wait until it's too late. They gave you life and they have to know. If they do not know you will have to keep running away from yourself all your life.

Flag as inappropriate

Brian and Peter at 5:04 PM on 4/7/2008

I am very sorry for your loss.
I have been a reader (and fan) of yours for more years than either one of us would care to admit. I keep several copies of your advice to the 15 year old boy looking to get laid. It's good advice to anyone, at any age.
I've always had a very good relationship with my mom. Coming out to her didn't change that. While she is still with us, she is getting on in years, and she has her share of health problems. And being an old nurse, she is fully aware that she is closer to the end than to the beginning. But she is still full of life, and most importantly LOVE. I don't honestly know what I'll do when she passes. I've lived my whole life, until recently, in the same city as my parents, and was always there for them in their time of medical need (I too am in the medical field). Now my partner and I live on the other side of the country. I'm pretty certain that I won't be there in the same room when her time comes. And I can't honestly say whether or not that's good or bad. Although we've never met, like many fans of 'celebrities,' I feel like I know you. Right now I feel your pain. I read the post from the Chicago cast of the Drowsy Chaperone. I am touched. I too will try to take a moment on friday to remember your mom, and mine.

Flag as inappropriate

Madrigaal at 12:54 AM on 4/8/2008

Dan:

Thank you so much for sharing you Mother with us. I have one of thoes PFLAG Mothers. Heck, I even got the PFLAG Father. I am a lucky, lucky guy (just like you) and I am glad you used the number three wood to slug me up 'side the heart.

I haven't had a good cry since early March. I find a good cry is great for what ails me (a generation of men I loved and was supposed to marry dying around me). So love on that kid, and that boyfriend. And remember, we love you because You are Your Mother's Son.

And all that entails.

Flag as inappropriate

Ana at 11:29 AM on 4/8/2008

Im soory for yuor lost at 13 my mother passed a sweet lady. it will be tough but you will go on and the pain does ease with time

Flag as inappropriate

Joe G at 12:44 PM on 4/8/2008

Good column, sad news--my heart goes out to you (it's a cliche, I know, but--). Both my parents have been gone about nine years & now I am nobody's child. You will always think about her, dream about her. That is not a bad thing.

Flag as inappropriate

Jenna at 9:02 PM on 4/8/2008

I'm having trouble typing through my tears. I just found I'm 5 weeks pregnant and I hope my child is as wonderful as you.

Flag as inappropriate

James Cappleman at 11:30 PM on 4/8/2008

Shit is right.

Thanks for sharing her with us. We need to hear your words and you needed to say them. I never knew your mom, but I sure as hell like her.

Flag as inappropriate

Chris Schneider at 9:40 AM on 4/9/2008

Dan, I'm so sorry for your loss. My heart goes out to you, my father (your mother practically raised my father), and the whole family. Shit.

Flag as inappropriate

Joe Dugan at 9:09 AM on 4/10/2008

Hey, Dan,

You DID write a column today. A GREAT one at that!

Flag as inappropriate

John Williams at 9:10 AM on 4/10/2008

Beautiful. Thank you.

Flag as inappropriate

Jan Shuman at 4:46 PM on 4/10/2008

Dear Dan, With tears in my eyes I thank you so much for your beautiful, heartfelt, and eloquent words. I am so very, very sorry for the loss of your beloved Mother, and of your son's beloved Grandmother. May your memories ease your sorrow and may you and your whole family go from strength to strength. Any time you do a good deed, learn something, or donate to charity in her memory, or solve a problem or handle a situation the way she would, you elevate her soul. By word and by deed she showed you how incredibly much she loved you and how very, very PROUD of you she was. May G-d bless you all. You are in my thoughts and prayers. Thinking of you, Jan

Flag as inappropriate

John at 9:32 PM on 4/10/2008

Dear Dan,

A lovely tribute to your mother. I am so sorry for your loss. Take care of yourself.

Flag as inappropriate

CAN at 1:31 PM on 4/11/2008

I'm sorry for you and your family. This column is beautiful. My mom died 14 years ago and I still think about her almost every day and sometimes, like reading this column today, I can still burst into tears about it. When I'm in a glass-half-full mood I tell myself the spontaneous bawling is a good thing -- it means I had a good mom and it's right to miss her. On other days it just pisses me off. It especially pisses me off that she died when my oldest son was not yet 1 and my youngest wasn't even born. Robbed them of an awesome grandmother. Robbed me of much needed advice. I don't know how it could be any other way. I'd be so incredibly proud if one of my son's ever wrote something so eloquent, funny and loving about me. She did good work and knowing that is an incredible gift for a parent. Peace be with you.

Flag as inappropriate

Bob at 4:37 PM on 4/11/2008

Dan,

I lost my mother this past January. She a was also an Irish Catholic lady with an acute B.S. detector. Anyway, while this is not an easy time for you I'm sure, you are blessed to have had a great relationship with your mom and that will last forever. Take as much time as you need and then get back to the dirty stuff. Please!

Flag as inappropriate

djr at 9:23 PM on 4/11/2008

Hello Dan. My sympathies are with you. Thank you for reconnecting me with my own mother who died 32 years ago, but who lives in my life and who i revisit through memories, especially at those other times in life when I need that support she gave back then. Your mother sounds like she was terrific. How lucky for you, right? d

Flag as inappropriate

Cara at 11:21 PM on 4/11/2008

Dear Dan,
My deepest sympathies to you aand your family. Your mother must have been so awesome to still love and appreciate you when you came out. My male gay friend still has his mother and she will never accept him and his legal husband. (in Canada anyway)What a beautiful tribute to her and your love for her.Losing a parent SUCKS! I lost my father a few years ago and I still have my Irish-Catholic mom with me.I know I will be lost without her. Just go with your emotions...even if that means crying in the supermarket. God Bless you!!

Flag as inappropriate

Mary Shen Barnidge at 11:50 PM on 4/11/2008

One of the blessings of being a writer is that you can find words to express your sorrow--almost. Permit me to extend my condolences to you and to your family.

Flag as inappropriate

mds at 9:37 AM on 4/12/2008

My wife's mother died 10 years ago this coming June the day before Fathers Day the same as my wife's father died 25 years earlier. After she died, my wife and her brothers and sisters had to divide all of her mom's treasures. My wife built a "shrine" of all of her mom's possessions on our kitchen table that lasted for about 6 months. But the day came where she was finally able to put this stuff either on proper display or storage. I'm sorry for your loss. Take your time. As the song goes, "Weep not for the memories"!

Flag as inappropriate

Angela Jacobi at 1:10 PM on 4/12/2008

Dear Dan, You would remember me as Angie Hollahan. I was married to Jim, I'm Myke's mother. If I had known about the funeral I'd have come, but I will be keeping all of you in my prayers. Your Mom's name will be mentioned at all the Masses at St Nicks in Evanston this weekend. Because words can't begin to say how sad I am. I've know your Mom 40+ years and I will always miss her love and wisdom. All my love and prayers to you and the whole family.

Flag as inappropriate

Amy A at 8:05 AM on 4/13/2008

Your Mother would be proud. This piece....you are so amazingly talented. It was incredibly well written. And again, you touched so many of us.
This gift...this talented writer that you are..is an extension of your mother. Remember that you will be honoring her every day than....in your columns.
Also remember that there are many who are walking this earth everyday sharing these same feelings of loss....we are all connected.....you are never alone......


Flag as inappropriate

Eileen at 10:14 AM on 4/13/2008

god bless, she sounds like a beautiful person. Hang in there.

Flag as inappropriate

Mary E at 11:48 AM on 4/13/2008

Hi Dan
My mama passed away two weeks ago, and she has been talking to me ever since. I happened upon your article while sitting in that coffee shop and bursting into tears. It was like she had turned the page for me and was asking me to keep remembering the person she was---through your story. Thanks for writing it Dan, and I will remember you and your mom as I celebrate the memories of mine.

Flag as inappropriate

Patrick S at 2:11 PM on 4/14/2008

Wow, I thought I could make it through these comments without crying. That plan was ruined by Paul who is a cast of Drowsy. I am one part very sad that you have lost such a wonderful mother, and one part jealous that you had such an accepting mother in the first place. She will have a special place in the hereafter.

Flag as inappropriate

albanypark at 8:28 PM on 4/14/2008

Very touching. I cried because I thought of my own mom who passed away 18 years ago. A mother's love is very special. Sorry for your loss.

Flag as inappropriate

Simone L at 9:01 PM on 4/16/2008

Dan,
I have always looked forward to your advice in the weekley City Paper when I lived in Pittsburgh and I was happy to see something that I loved here in the Chicago Reader. I am very sorry for your loss and thou you may have taken a week off you still manage to touch us in a different way. That was a beautiful story about your mother and I'm happy that you were able to share it with us. Your mother is very pround of you and from your story she has always been. Continue to make her proud and remember she will be with you always. I will keep you and your family in my prayers. =)

Flag as inappropriate

Martha T at 7:49 PM on 4/20/2008

Shit, indeed. I am so sorry to hear about your mom, but so happy to read your fond memories. I lost my mother almost 13 years ago to respiratory disease. Few days go by that I don't think of her and the huge influence she had on my life. Your plan to take some time off to process is wise. Be kind to yourself and revel in the fact that you know you are loved.

Add a comment

Required, but will never be displayed

This math problem is an anti-spam measure

(please read our policy)

 



We welcome your comments and suggestions. Click here to send us a message.

©1996-2008 Creative Loafing Media All Rights Reserved.