The Police Torture Scandal: A Who's Who 

5. Took the Fifth (Or Intend To)

Since the first reports of Chicago police torture surfaced a quarter century ago the list has swelled to nearly 200 cases involving dozens of public employees—and still no one has been prosecuted. Now, with the results of a four-year, multimillion dollar investigation due any day, here’s a guide by staff reporter John Conroy to the key figures in the scandal. Some of them may look familiar.

Three officers are known to have been granted immunity from prosecution by the special prosecutor: MICHAEL HOKE, Commander PATRICK GARRITY, and former detective DANIEL MCWEENY. Garrity is not considered a regular member of the Burge gang but does figure prominently in the case of Madison Hobley, one of four victims pardoned by Governor Ryan. McWeeny appears more regularly, sometimes as the detective who comes in after the torture to take the victim’s confession.

The names of other officers who have testified before the Burge grand jury have not been revealed, but court records list the names of police officers who participated in arrests and interrogations. Many have been deposed in the last few years in active civil suits and other proceedings related to the torture of suspects. Under questioning, the vast majority took the Fifth. They’ve likely also been subpoenaed to appear before the special prosecutor’s grand jury. The 26 officers and former officers listed below have either invoked their Fifth Amendment privileges when questioned about the torture or declared their intention to do so in documents related to ongoing civil suits. According to People’s Law Office attorney Flint Taylor, nine more officers have taken the Fifth, but their depositions are under seal.

Former assistant deputy superintendent Michael Hoke
Former commander Jon Burge
Commander Patrick Garrity (granted immunity)
Former lieutenant Peter Dignan
Former lieutenant Dennis McGuire
Former sergeant John Byrne
Sergeant Raymond Madigan
Detective Robert Dwyer
Detective Edmund Leracz
Former detective Leonard Bajenski
Former detective Ronald Boffo
Former detective Michael Bosco
Former detective Joseph Danzl
Former detective Joseph DiGiacomo
Former detective David Dioguardi
Former detective Robert Flood
Former detective Fred Hill
Former detective Anthony Katalinic
Former detective James Lotito
Former detective William Marley
Former detective Thomas McKenna
Former detective Raymond McNally
Former detective Daniel McWeeny (granted immunity)
Former detective John Paladino
Former detective William Pedersen
Former detective James Pienta


An archive of John Conroy's reporting on the police torture scandal is available at chicagoreader.com/policetorture.

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

More by John Conroy

Agenda Teaser

Galleries & Museums
De Nue LeRoy Neiman Center Lobby
September 02
Performing Arts
Mamma Mia! Paramount Theatre
September 07

Tabbed Event Search

Popular Stories

Follow Us

Sign up for newsletters »

 Early Warnings
 Food & Drink
 Reader Recommends
 Reader Events and Offers
30 Years After A Nuclear Disaster, Chernobyl Wildlife Is Thriving