Chicago Reader

Wednesday, May 7, 2008

Gee, how will they vote?

Posted by Mick Dumke on Wed, May 7, 2008 at 4:08 PM

The Chicago Plan Commission is set to take up the Chicago Children’s Museum’s plans to move into Grant Park at its May 15 meeting, and the safe bet is on the museum getting its way. Why? Well, the commission rarely sees a high-powered zoning change it doesn’t like. Then there’s the rather vocal position of its most important member, Mayor Daley. And finally there's the matter of the individual loyalties and ties of all the other commissioners:

  • Linda Searl, chair: A partner in the respected Searl Lamaster Howe architectural firm, Searl is ten-year veteran of the commission, a donor to Daley’s campaign committee, and a longtime adviser to Daley and the city’s planning department.
  • Mayor Richard M. Daley: Didn’t we hear something about how he’s going to look out for the children?
  • Arnold L. Randall: As the commissioner for the city’s planning department, he reports to Mayor Daley.
  • Tom Byrne: As the commissioner of the city’s Department of Transportation, he reports to Mayor Daley.
  • David Weinstein: Now the president of the Chicagoland Entrepreneurial Center, a nonprofit affiliate of the Chicagoland Chamber of Commerce, which receives thousands of dollars a year in city funding. He formerly served as the mayor’s “technology adviser.”
  • Alderman William J.P. Banks: The northwest side alderman chairs the City Council’s powerful zoning committee—which would take up this proposal next if the commission passes it. He's one of Daley’s staunchest council backers and proud of it.
  • Patricia Scudiero: Scudiero is the top official—officially the "administrator"—for the city’s Department of Zoning, which enforces and interprets the city’s zoning code. As the Chicago Tribune has reported, Scudiero formerly served on Banks’s zoning committee staff and worked for the planning department.
  • Alderman Edward M. Burke: Among his many intertwining business and political relationships, the City Council’s finance committee chairman has received numerous campaign contributions from museum board secretary Matthew Neumeier.
  • Leon D. Finney, Jr.: Finney was one of the mayor’s earliest and most vocal supporters in the black community, and the nonprofit he leads, the Woodlawn Organization, has received millions of dollars from the city for social service and public housing programs.
  • Alderman Mary Ann Smith: Smith often touts her independence but is usually a reliable council vote for the mayor’s initiatives. She’s enthusiastically supported the Daley administration’s ever-expanding use of TIFs, including several in and around her 48th Ward, and she’s got a record of using hardball tactics and backroom deals to eliminate political opposition.
  • Doris B. Holleb: The University of Chicago trustee and professor of economics and urban planning has served as a consultant to the city’s planning department and an education, economics, and cultural adviser to the Carter, Reagan, and Clinton administrations. Her husband, Marshall, is a widely respected preservationist and attorney who has donated thousands of dollars to numerous political campaigns, including those of aldermen Smith and Banks.
  • Lyneir Richardson: Richardson is a registered City Hall lobbyist for General Growth Properties, a real estate firm that develops, owns, and manages shopping malls in 45 states. The firm has received hundreds of millions of dollars in tax breaks around the country, according to a study by SEIU, which has been in a pissing match with it over procedures for unionizing employees.
  • Carole Brown: Besides being appointed by the mayor to chair the CTA’s board, Brown is a member of the Children’s Museum board.
  • Smita Shah: She’s the president and CEO of SPAAN Technology, which last fall received a $5 million city contract to provide engineering services for the city’s transportation department. The firm has also done work for the CTA and Chicago Public Schools.
  • George W. Migala: Migala’s a radio broadcaster and station executive at WCEV 1450-AM.
  • Alderman Patrick O'Connor: As Daley’s unofficial City Council floor leader, he’s about as loyal as they come. He’s currently got a campaign war chest of about $400,000, much of it contributed by developers, realtors, and construction interests.
  • John H. Nelson: Nelson, a $5,500 donor to Mayor Daley’s 2007 reelection campaign, is an architect with Harley Ellis Devereaux, whose work includes the Boeing Galleries in Millennium Park, the 18th District police station, and the Picnic Grove Pavilion at the Lincoln Park Zoo.
  • Nancy A. Pacher: Pacher is president and chief operating officer of U.S. Equities, an international real estate firm that has received millions of dollars in city business for property management and consulting work on TIFs.
  • Alderman Bernard L. Stone: Stone isn’t above berating a city official when he’s worked up during a meeting of the City Council’s buildings committee, which he chairs. He’s not even above stalling what he deems “stupid” ordinances some of these officials occasionally send him. But after more than three decades as an alderman, he’s not going to suddenly become an independent. Like most other influential aldermen, Stone receives thousands of dollars in political contributions from developers every campaign cycle.
  • Gracia M. Shiffrin: Now the senior director for development and construction programs for Catholic Charities, Shiffrin previously held several high-ranking positions in the Daley administration, including deputy chief of staff to Daley, assistant planning commissioner, and assistant corporation counsel.
  • Alderman Regner "Ray" Suarez: As chairman of the council’s housing committee, Suarez is a proud defender of the Daley administration’s housing and development record. He too is able to rake in campaign contributions—about $147,000 in just the last six months of 2007, when he wasn’t running for anything. As with his council colleagues on the Plan Commission, Suarez collected a good chunk of his cash from developers and construction companies. But he’s the only one who will be faced with a conflict of interest if the entity known as Fullerton Cicero Donuts ever has a matter before the commission. It gave him $1,025 last year.

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Comments (15) RSS

Showing 1-15 of 15

Add a comment

Generic user icon

Limit political contributions to $10 per person, only from individuals and only from those individuals qualified to vote for the specific candidate's office. That would put a dent in the current systematic 'legal' bribery influencing all elections, especially local ones, ie. city, township and county. Politics is local and, thus, opportunities for this 'legal' bribery from elements not local should be eliminated. How about conducting an on-line poll to see how many citizens would support, and vote for, a binding referendum on the above?

Posted by Solutions on May 7, 2008 at 5:39 PM | Report this comment
Generic user icon

the majority view is carefully cast in law Muni Code 2-120-380 (with comments) The Chicago plan commission shall be composed of 22 members: (9) nine members who are lay citizens, to be appointed by the mayor with the approval of the city council, and (13) ex officio the mayor, (Daley) the president of the board of local improvements, (is this what we now know as the Public Buildings Commission? if so, Daley chairs PBC) (3) Dept heads the commissioner of planning and development, (Arnold L. Randall) the zoning administrator, (Patricia Scudiero) the commissioner of transportation, (Thomas G. Byrne) (6) Chairs of City Council Committees the chairman of the city council committee on buildings, (Stone) the chairman of the city council committee on finance, (Burke) the chairman of the city council committee on zoning, (Banks) the chairman of the city council committee on housing, (Suarez) the chairman of the city council committee on traffic control and safety, (should be Ald. Tom Allen, but not on PC?) the chairman of the city council committee on parks and recreation, (MA Smith) (2) Other agencies the general superintendent and chief executive officer of the Chicago Park District (should be Tim Mitchell, but not on PC?) and the chairman of the board of the Chicago Transit Authority. (Brown) The mayor shall designate a chairman and vice-chairman from among the appointed members. The appointed members shall hold no other public office except where such public office is nonsalaried and no fees or emoluments are derived therefrom.

Posted by Hugh on May 7, 2008 at 5:51 PM | Report this comment
Generic user icon

22 members, and 1 is the mayor and 3 are dept heads and 6 are aldermen. As if they don't have enough influence on City policy already. The 9 "lay" members have no chance of representing real people. The Plan Commission is carefully designed to be a rubber stamp venue for when state law calls for public hearing.

Posted by Hugh on May 7, 2008 at 5:58 PM | Report this comment
Generic user icon

conspicuously absent from the enabling legislation of the Plan Commission: the chairman of the city council committee on Historical Landmark Preservation oops!

Posted by Hugh on May 7, 2008 at 6:09 PM | Report this comment
Generic user icon

Alderman O'Connor is a corrupt joke. Catholic Charities should be separated from the Catholic Church.

Posted by old greek on May 7, 2008 at 7:28 PM | Report this comment
Generic user icon

coco rat is a idiot.first he sez is going after banks and silvestri on his site.now he sez he has a soft spot.sounds like old coco rat is sacred and backed off.why dumb bell???

Posted by ??CoCo Rat?? on May 7, 2008 at 8:18 PM | Report this comment
Generic user icon

We made Coconuts a offer he couldn't refuse!

Posted by Mike Corleone, Godfather 36th ward. on May 7, 2008 at 9:26 PM | Report this comment
Generic user icon

Put the Childrens Museum in Pilsen. It is close to public transportation and the highways, there is parking, it is in area with lots of kids. Grant Park has too much opposition. The Pilsen community will not oppose it and it can serve children all over the city but especially Hispanics and Blacks in Little Village, North Lawndale, McKinley Park, Bridgeport, Brighton Park, what's left of the Housing Projects and the Near South and West Sides. We can get Fioretti and Reily to support this.

Posted by Danny Solis on May 7, 2008 at 11:15 PM | Report this comment
Generic user icon

Maybe Daley really means it, when he says that he's dedicated to making this museum accessible to the children of the minorities, maybe it's the people who own the Children's Museum who don't want to have their museum located within the minority communities they purport to be interested in serving. Maybe they are the folks who don't want the museum to be where some of their customers live. Maybe Daley truly cares about these 'under-privileged' children and would welcome the Children's Museum choosing to locate their museum within one, or more, of the 'minority' neighborhoods, but they, the Children's Museum owners, prefer their museum to be located where they'll have primarily tourists and suburbanites utilizing it. Maybe, if Daley truly had his way, the Children's Museum would be 'encouraged' to build their new museum, or museums, within the very neighborhoods where they claim their museum is most needed. Maybe the current proposed location isn't only about money, only about impressing tourists, only about pretending that the very neighborhoods where the kids need this museum most aren't good enough for the Children's Museum to be built in. Maybe it's not Daley's fault that he's being forced to back the Children Museum's proposed plan, maybe the mayor isn't as powerful as we all believe he is, maybe he's been made an offer he 'can't refuse'. Maybe. Maybe Poor Richie really wants to do the right thing, but doesn't have the power to refuse the Children Museum's owners, doesn't have the power to influence what the Commission decides, doesn't have the power to say no those who tell him when to say yes. Maybe. And maybe ducks wear boots.

Posted by Maybe..... on May 8, 2008 at 12:08 AM | Report this comment
Generic user icon

The deck may be stacked but the cause is not lost. Show up at the Plan Commission meeting on May 15, 1pm at City Hall. Go www.savegrantpark.org and www.savelincolnpark.org and sign our online petitions and contribute!

Posted by Park Champion on May 8, 2008 at 7:52 AM | Report this comment
Generic user icon

Anyone doing a running tally of who is for or against the park in terms of aldermen? Suarez, OConnor, Banks are no votes, who else? We all KNOW the Commission will pass it, that is a no brainer.

Posted by LES on May 8, 2008 at 8:57 AM | Report this comment
Generic user icon

In the enabling legislation of the Plan Commission you can almost see that perhaps it was designed to foster communication between the mayor, department heads, aldermen, and citizens, to force them to sit down and look at each other and confront the great development issues of the day. But any earlier problems with communications between the mayor, department heads, and aldermen are ancient history. We now have a new problem: PERFECT communication between the mayor, dept. heads, and aldermen. They are all always on EXACTLY the same page. The "lay" members who are supposed to represent real people are the odd men out. The Plan Commission has outlived its usefulness. It's time to rip it out and start over.

Posted by Hugh on May 8, 2008 at 9:47 AM | Report this comment
Generic user icon

Thanks for the great studies, Mick and Hugh. It turns out I was almost done researching the same survey for the Lincoln Park soccer field thing when I found this. My results were pretty similar, I missed a few things, but I also came up with a few other things: Chicago Plan Commission * Linda Searl, chair. Has sat on Landmarks Preservation Council. Worked for Jim Nagle at Nagle Hartray. Sits on Graham Foundation with Nagle. Lives in Ukrainian Village, near Jonathan Fine. * Ald. William J.P. Banks. Always sounds civil, parliamentarian, and rational, but when all is said and done faithfully advances pro-development, pro-mayoral initiatives. Drives the notorious rubber stamp that is the Zoning Committee, and likely has political sway in the CPC. Parliamentary expert. No humility, no mentors. * Ald. Edward Burke. Like Banks, almost always a sanctimonious loyalist who can make whatever argument he wants. Probably the most powerful alderman by most measures. Wife of Illinois justice Ann Burke. Parliamentary expert. No humility, no mentors. * Mayor Richard M. Daley. * David Weinstein. Young Kellogg alum 2000, “bristles with…gritty, get-deals-done energy” (Kellogg alumni magazine Spring ‘07). Runs Chicagoland Entrepreneurial Center, akin to a chamber of commerce. 1996-2000 Chicago tech adviser. Founder, Blue Meteor. J.B. Pritzker, Michael Ferro, Larry Levy (Kellogg ‘67) and James Tyree have all invested in CEC, which has many institutional sponsors. * Rev. Dr. Leon D. Finney, Jr. Long, storied history. Founder, Metropolitan Apostolic Community Church. The Woodlawn Organization chairman. Hyde Park elite. Close to Barack Obama and Rev. Jeremiah Wright. Won a 2000 one-bid federal contract for his Lincoln South Central Real Estate Group to rent space for a VA clinic. Loyal campaign contributor to Daley. Wife Georgette Greenley-Finney, who runs TWO appears to be inappropriately lobbying for the museum * Doris B. Holleb. Renowned social economist and champion of affordable housing. Clinton 1996 pick for National Council on the Humanities. Studied Harvard, taught U of C. Lives in 43rd Ward with husband Marshall M. Holleb at 2650 Lakeview. Marshall is a Wildman Harrold attorney and trustee of Museum of Contemporary Art. * D. Lyneir Richardson. VP, urban land development at national shopping-mall developer General Growth. GGP founder is Matthew Bucksbaum, who with wife Carolyn lives in 42nd Ward at Hancock Building, unit 7001. Founder’s son and current GGP CEO is John Bucksbaum (wife Jacolyn), who until Oct. 2007 lived in 43rd Ward at 1852 N. Burling. Jacolyn is on Latin School board of trustees. * Carole Brown. CTA board chair. Unswerving Daley tool. CCM board member. * Smita Shah. Engineer, entrepreneur and high-powered contractor for Daley. Among other things, she did an O’Hare runway. But also a board member of ELPC. Probably reachable through ELPC and Howard Learner. * Tom Byrne. (Thomas G. Byrne, not to be confused with Thomas J. Byrne, the prosecutor and judicial candidate.) Former Police Department deputy superintendent, moved to CDOT commissioner by Mayor Daley. Can push him on traffic problem here, superior traffic and parking opportunities at alternative locations. * Arnold Randall. DPD commissioner. Need I say more? He has been working for the mayor since about 1995. * George W. Migala. Station manager of Polish radio station WCEV. gwm@migala.com * Ald. Patrick O’Connor (40). The mayor’s floor leader. A tool. Wife CCM board member. * John H. Nelson. High-powered Chicago architect. Big contributor to Mayor Daley. * Nancy A. Pacher. President of U.S. Equities, a building management and equity company that is a breeding ground for Daley loyalists. The company manages many of the largest buildings the city and county own, including the Washington Library and the County Building. * Ald. Mary Ann Smith (40). Who knows which way she will go on this? Probably whatever way Vi seems to lean. As parks chair, she will have a big say, so she should be lobbied directly. * Ald. Bernard Stone (50). Complete Daley tool. But he does support Save Grant Park. * Gracia Shiffrin. Former Mayoral staffer. Don’t know what she is doing now. * Ald. Ray Suarez (22). Daley’s vice mayor. Complete Daley tool. * Patricia Scudiero. Top Daley zoning administrator from 1988-2004.

Posted by Peter Zelchenko on May 10, 2008 at 7:36 PM | Report this comment
Generic user icon

Know Your Plan Commissioners correction (thanks, Peter!) the chairman of the city council committee on traffic control and safety, (Ald. O'Connor)

Posted by Hugh on May 14, 2008 at 12:12 PM | Report this comment
Generic user icon

It's as if you had a crystal ball! And who wasn't expecting this. A campaign of clout, lies and secrecy. I attended the circus and had to leave before even getting to the microphone. CCM was allowed 1:20 for their dog & pony show, to which you're correct, they were thanked for.

Posted by Molly on May 16, 2008 at 11:03 AM | Report this comment

Add a comment

Latest in The Blog

Author Archives

  • Parking meter lawsuit stayin' alive

    A lawsuit against the city and state over the parking meter lease agreement is moving forward, which puts the office of Illinois attorney general Lisa Madigan in an interesting spot, since it's still conducting its own investigation of the deal.
    • Sep 14, 2009
  • Exelon lobbies for green jobs money

    • Aug 24, 2009
  • The Big Green Apple

    Never mind your rooftop gardens and LEED buildings—here’s why New York is a model of sustainability.
    • Sep 24, 2009
  • More»

Recent Comments

©2009 Creative Loafing Media
All Rights Reserved.