Thursday, March 13, 2008
News / News Bites Northwestern's president and provost to Medill faculty: Enough.
Posted by Michael Miner on Thu, Mar 13, 2008 at 7:52 PM
The president and provost of Northwestern University held a meeting Thursday afternoon with the dean and faculty of Medill. President Henry Bienen responded to the polite hand he got when he was introduced with the ominous “I’m glad you’re clapping now. Some of you may not be in a few minutes.”
Bienen and provost Daniel Linzer made it clear they stand behind Medill dean John Lavine, who Bienen said was appointed to bring the school “into the modern world” after a couple of academic audits three years ago prescribed major change. NU has committed millions of dollars to the process, said Bienen, and “something good is happening.” Bienen concluded by citing a famous book written by Albert Hirschman in 1970, Exit, Voice, and Loyalty: Responses to Decline in Firms, Organizations, and States. There are three ways a worker can respond to unwelcome change, Hirschman said: he can buy into it, he can speak out and mediate, or he can leave. Faculty members familiar with the book felt that Bienen emphasized the third. “It’s a big world," Bienen said. "Find another university.”
Then Linzer commented on what Medill students have taken to calling Quotegate--allegations that last year Lavine made up a quote and claimed it came from a student praising a marketing class. Linzer appointed an ad hoc committee to look into the matter and two weeks ago announced that the committee had cleared the dean. At the faculty meeting, Linzer refused to say if the committee had actually turned in a report, let alone what criteria it had used and what evidence it had reviewed. Linzer’s reply was that the process confidential and he had no intention of saying a word more. “Once a decision has been made it has been made,” said the provost. “Then we move on.”
The faculty’s sense of aggrievement runs a lot deeper than Quotegate, which might not have amounted to much if so many professors didn’t already feel Lavine was running roughshod over them as he overhauled the curriculum. Professor Jack Doppelt asked Bienen one of the few questions; he wondered why it was necessary for Lavine to suspend faculty governance in order to revamp the curriculum. Doppelt called that a “toxic statement” from the administration to the faculty. Bienen replied that he didn’t think faculty governance had completely disappeared, but that at any rate Lavine was under orders to move with dispatch.
Bienen also said he was puzzled by why the Chicago press has been paying so much attention to Medill recently. He supposed it was a good thing, in that it shows that people care. It's really not such a good thing. It's possible that Quotegate has run its course--there’s probably no way of proving or disproving that Lavine was quoting someone, and Linzer made it clear that as far as NU concerned, the subject’s closed. But the provenance of a quote is one of those niggling details that do matter to journalists, and the failure of Lavine and his superiors to show they even understand that is a big reason why the press has been so relentless--consider these pieces by Eric Zorn --and so damning.
PS: Isn't Exit, Voice, and Loyalty a book that belongs on every newspaper person's desk?
Showing 1-5 of 5
screw withholding monetary gifts... how about Medill alumni assemble a class-action lawsuit to recover tuition from a school they *thought* they attended with a reputation that these himbos are paid to uphold? Bienen should grow some stones and fire Lavine, but it sounds like the NU prez has already drunk the Kool-Aid.
The outrage, here, is also over a very nasty statement by Medill's Chief Marketing Officer, Tom Hayden, that apparently, from what I've read about the matter, went out to the entire Medill community via a listserv. Would someone please do a writeup about the absolutely undignified manner in which a Medill senior was attacked for his credibility through an official communications channel? I mean, I think a LOT of NU students in many of the various schools throughout the university would be shocked to learn that they were being sniped at by a top officer or dean via a listserv. I mean, that's just entirely out of line. Please find the Hayden letter and report on it, because it's an absolute disgrace. And to think that I had actually ordered info on the various Medill programs a while back. Never again. Why not just put some of the Medill degree programs online and turn it into one of those Career Education type for-profit schools? I mean, why not just cheapen the school's reputation farther? Sad.
OK, I've been out of Medill for 20 years but I don't understand the need for a Chief Marketing Officer. What in the world are they marketing? The school to prospective students? The reputation to employers? Valued, trustworthy student-produced content to media organizations? Peace of mind to students' parents? Trust to alumni? It'd be interesting to see measurements of performance in these areas over the last two years because it doesn't seem to be working.
Well, half the school is devoted to teaching marketing -- Integrated Marketing Communications. It's not surprising they'd have a person help run that.
I get that Levine made a mistake, but does it mean that every person who has ever worked for or graduated from Medill has lost credibility? In the scheme of things doesn't everybody make these kinds of mistakes? I've been quoted in the newspaper many times and I have yet to find one that is an actual verbatim quote. Life goes on.
Latest in The Blog
-
Locust Music Hosts an Eclectic Saturday Showcase
Chicago's eclectic Locust Music label hosts a typically diverse showcase—with Starless & Bible Black, Stephen Titra's O.W.L., Paul Metzger, and more—at the Empty Bottle on Saturday night.
- Nov 6, 2009
-
Lynda Barry, Matt Groening, Chris Ware, and Jules Feiffer in a discussion Saturday at Parker
Matt Groening, Lynda Barry, Chris Ware, and Jules Feiffer join the Reader's Michael Miner for a discussion on the declining business of weekly comics.
- Nov 6, 2009
-
11/9—"Site Unseen" at the Chicago Cultural Center
Site Unseen 2009 at the Chicago Cultural Center, curated by Julie Laffin
- Nov 6, 2009
- More»
Author Archives
-
Ben Eason on what happens next
Creative Loafing CEO ponders the future following the loss of his company to his main creditor.
- Aug 25, 2009
-
Whose News Is It Anyway?
There's constant chatter on local blogs and tweets about when the limits of aggregation are being exceeded in Chicago. At the Hartford Courant recently there was no argument.
- Sep 3, 2009
-
Chicago Reader enters Atalaya Era
Creative Loafing loses its last bid in bankruptcy court, and its main creditor takes the reins at the Reader.
- Aug 25, 2009
- More»
Comments (5) RSS