
In a double review, Albert Williams expresses admiration for the American Theater Company rethinking of Rent and the Porchlight revival of Tick Tick . . . Boom!. Both musicals were written by Jonathan Larson, who famously died the day before the original production of Rent opened. Keith Griffith enjoyed the "whirlwind erudition" of Tom Stoppard's Arcadia, at New Leaf Theatre, and the rough charm of Peter Pan’s Shadow Part Two: Everland, which is the latest entry in a new trilogy by Jeremy Menekseoglu. Jack Helbig liked the "beguiling simplicity and grace"—not to mention the "satisfying punch"—of Prologue Theatre's Romeo-and-Juliet-down-south show, Take her to See the Maco Lights. Julia Thiel fell in love with My Asian Mom, a collection of short works from A-Squared Theatre. And even I liked something enough to recommend it: Gorilla Tango's macabre musical goof on the 80s-era sitcom Full House, Attend the Tale of Danny Tanner.
But we're not out of kudos yet.
Tony Adler called The Iceman Cometh "great in its excess" when he reviewed Robert Falls's Goodman Theatre staging of it 22 years ago; seeing Falls's new version, he's impressed by its comic structure. Circle Theatre takes a pleasantly surprising turn away from its usual formula of crowd-pleasing musicals and comedies with When the Rain Stops Falling, a sensitive, layered portrait of a family that spans two continents and four generations. Debra Ehrhardt takes a different approach to international relations in Jamaica Farewell, her one-woman memoir about getting to Miami with help from a nice CIA agent. For dance this week, Laura Molzahn likes the collaborative performance involving Muntu Dance Theatre and DanceWorks Chicago.

The hoochie coochie was performed inside the fair's Algerian Village—one the many "ethnic" villages along the Midway Plaisance. Thousands migrated toward the Algerian Village to see the dance performed by the infamous Little Egypt. The audiences grew so large that Bloom claimed he was making $1,000 per week.

Drawing on another facet of pop culture, Tympanic Theatre spins the ten tracks of Bruce Springsteen's bleak 1982 album Nebraska into a gritty series of short plays, Deliver Us From Nowhere: Tales From Nebraska. It too earns a Reader rave.
Where Springsteen and Tympanic find pathos, White Trash Wedding and a Funeral finds hilarity. Its hero, a cussing septic tank "king" named Earl, leads a band of down-and-outs through a grotesquely funny trailer-park soap opera. Equally over the top: the burlesque comedy show Day Drinking and Sleep Eating, which fulfills its promise to "funny you until you can't walk right" with songs like "Long Sex Is Overrated" and "Sluts for Sale." Far more restrained but equally engaging is the Piven Theatre Workshop's Encores: After the Theatre and Other Stories, in which three Anton Chekov stories are given minimalist, emotionally intense stagings. Director Joyce Piven uses the story-theater style originated here in Chicago by her mentor, Paul Sills.
Also on our recommended list this week is Hairspray, Drury Lane Oakbrook's high-energy revival of the Broadway musical; The Late Live Show, a Conan-esque talk fest hosted by comedian Joe Kwaczala at Stage 773; and an appearance by Armitage Gone! Dance, offering three works choreographed by company artistic director Karole Armitage.
Surprisingly, the problem with Melancholy Play isn't that it's a downer, but that it suffers from an overdose of quirk. And Neil LaBute's In a Forest, Dark and Deep turns out not to be so dark or deep after all. According to Justin Hayford's lead review, it's fairly obvious and mechanical.

Other shows with strong temporal ties get more love. Though Jersey Boys plays on 60s nostalgia, it doesn't gloss over the rocky relationships among Frankie Valli and his fellow Four Seasons. And Marriott Theatre manages to preserve the spirit of the 1879 Gilbert & Sullivan romp The Pirates of Penzance while appealing to contemporary audiences.

Speaking of clashes, a long and very bloody one between Germany and its colonial subjects is the focus of—wait for it—We Are Proud to Present a Presentation About the Herero of Namibia, Formerly Known as South-West Africa, From the German Sudwestafrika, Between the Years 1884-1915, which I found disappointing despite its dynamism. Genesis Theatrical Productions' Tunnel Rat concerns an American soldier caught in the clash between the United States and Vietnam.

Out of the ten other productions reviewed this week, only two rated outright recommendations from our critics. Kerry Reid likes Freud's Last Session, which offers a what-if colloquy between the iconic psychiatrist of the title and the man who imagined Narnia, C.S. Lewis. Jack Helbig, meanwhile, is properly creeped out by a stripped-down stage adaptation of Henry James's The Turn of the Screw, presented by First Folio out in Oakbrook.

Speaking of dark, Laura Molzahn suggests you see the Same Planet Different World 15th-anniversary show, "Fifteen," which features Joanna Rosenthal's despairing It Is What It Is. Also good and dark are Theatre Seven's version of the Naomi Wallace play In the Heart of America and Redtwist's The Laramie Project: Ten Years Later. Keith Griffith recommends El Stories from the Waltzing Mechanics, and Kerry Reid likes what City Lit has done with one of her favorite Shirley Jackson stories, We Have Always Lived in the Castle.
Less enthusiastically received: Chicago Fusion's Las Hermanas Padilla, the Agency's Paradise Lost (not Milton's but Clifford Odets's), and Raven Theatre's staging of Arthur Miller's The Price. Zac Thompson protests that Sarah Gubbins's YA play about bullying, FML: How Carson McCullers Saved My Life, isn't dark enough
Albert Williams recommends Porchlight Music Theatre's version of A Catered Affair, saying that where Broadway blew the intimate Harvey Fierstein/John Bucchino musical out of proportion, Porchlight gets it right. Laura Molzahn, meanwhile, suggests you get a look at the innovative form of flamenco practiced by New York's A Palo Seco. The company is appearing at two venues—the Old Town School of Folk Music and Instituto Cervantes.